Monday, August 13, 2007


The Powers That Be

Is it too late to apologize to King George III? And, of course, return to British rule here in the States. No, wait... Texas should return to Mexico. No, wait... to Spain. No, wait... let’s take it all the way back. Let’s all be Romans!

There are a lot of people who want to read Romans 13 as a commandment for all times. While I think the teachings and principles contained in Romans 13 speak to us, I believe that Paul was speaking to a specific situation. I don’t believe in the “divine right of kings.” I don’t believe that it was God’s will that Hitler come to power, nor that we can hold Him directly responsible for every king that ever walked the face of the earth.

Paul writes to the Roman Christians that should submit “to the powers that exist.” I believe that they were not to rebel against the Roman empire, that they were to follow the laws of the empire. This would facilitate the preaching of the gospel and postpone the inevitable persecution. I believe that he was giving a teaching for that specific situation.

He goes on to say: “For rulers are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Would you have no fear of the one who is in authority? Then do what is good, and you will receive his approval, for he is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain. For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God’s wrath on the wrongdoer.”
(Romans 13:3-4) Are we willing to say that Paul, Peter and all of the Christian martyrs were wrongdoers? If they had done good, they would have received the approval of the emperor... if this passage was meant to apply to all situations at all times. We can’t apply this passage universally without being forced to make some ridiculous statements about who did good and who was a wrongdoer.

And that doesn’t include all the questions that arise during civil wars, revolutions, coup d’etats, etc. Even wars are problematic... If one authority orders us to attack one of the other “existing powers,” should we obey? Or are we going against God’s appointed?

Let’s read this passage in its context. The principles of respect continue. The principle of following laws that don’t go against God’s law continues. But let’s not get too carried away with applying this passage.

2 comments:

AncientWanderer said...

Of Course I Have To Disagree-

God put Pharaoh in power to do His very will.....

I think God put Hitler in power too. We had the chance to stop him before a single minute of the holocaust began but we didn't.

AND, WWI & WWII were responsible for the spread of the Gospel world wide in our life times like no other event before in our "American" history.

BUT I DO AGREE THAT THE PRINCIPLE IS TO RESPECT AUTHORITY.

Tim Archer said...

If God put Hitler in power, who had the right to take him out? And, according to Paul, anyone who did right had nothing to fear from him. So why would we oppose him? He was only punishing wrongdoers... unless this passage doesn't apply to all people, all times.

The Roman emperors at the time of Paul were vicious, cruel, immoral, ungodly men, so that's not an excuse for opposing such leaders today. If this passage is universal and eternal, good people have nothing to fear from any government.

---Tim

P.S.--You do know you're posting on my "alternate blog," right?